Building An Empire

Welcome back to Eye for Engineering for, at long last, another post. It’s been a while but here it is.

Having looked to the future with the previous entry, Reach for the Sky, for this post I will be looking to the past with a tribute to some of history’s foremost engineers: the Romans.

The Roman Empire

The Roman Empire

It is impossible to study ancient history without acknowledging the influence of the Romans. With their civilization having spanned over a thousand years, their advancements in the fields of warfare, engineering, medicine, and culture would not be seen again until at modern times.

There are many ways to judge a civilization, though. The roman legions are considered to have been the most effective fighting force in history until the advent of gunpowder. With them, Rome rose from a single city state in the 4th century BC to an empire that controlled the entire Mediterranean Sea by the end of the 1st century AD, and remained the dominant military power for centuries afterwards. Yet other cultures had accomplished equally impressive military feats before. Alexander the Great had conquered his entire empire, stretching from Greece and Egypt to the borders of India, in just over 10 years. Rome’s dominant culture and religion was derived from its subject nations – mainly Greece, with Rome adopting the entire Greek pantheon and mythology under different names. Similarly, much of Rome’s medical knowledge was influenced by the Greeks’.

The Romans did, however, excel over all their predecessors and contemporaries in one area. In this area they would be unparalleled until the modern day, and their developments would give inspiration even from the Renaissance period. That field is engineering: the Romans had exceptional engineers and built roads, buildings, bridges, aqueducts, and siege engines like the world had never seen and would not see again until the Renaissance. History is awash with empires rising through conquest, and scientific discoveries have been rediscovered and disproven, but for any nation to be strong it requires infrastructure, and this the Romans had.

 

Pont Julien bridge, Calavon River, France. The old roman bridge (foreground) dates back to the first century BC and carried traffic, even cars, up to 2005 when the new bridge (background) was constructed (Pont Julien)

Pont Julien bridge, Calavon River, France. The old roman bridge (foreground) dates back to the first century BC and carried traffic, even cars, up to 2005 when the new bridge (background) was constructed

De Architectura:

We owe most of our knowledge of Roman engineering and architecture not only to numerous surviving examples but to the architect Vitruvius, who compiled the treatise De Architectura for his patron Augustus Caesar, the emperor of Rome. De Architectura was written in ten volumes, each of which discussed a topic of engineering important to the empire:

  • Book I: Town Planning
  • Book II: Building Materials
  • Books III and IV: Temples and orders of architecture
  • Book V: Civil/Public Buildings
  • Book VI: Domestic/Private Buildings
  • Book VII: Pavements and plasterwork
  • Book VIII: Aqueducts and water
  • Book IX: Architectural sciences (geometry, sundials…)
  • Book X: Machinery

De Architectura was written to serve as a guide for Augustus Caesar to all the types of engineering and architecture that would be of use to him in building his empire. He would not be the only one to make use of it: Vitruvius’ work was the reference for all further architectural treatises until the 18th century, and is the only surviving work of its kind from the classical era, thus serving as modern historians’ only reference to classical architecture and engineering. The principles illustrated in De Architectura can be found in hundreds of surviving Roman works around the Mediterranean.

Building Materials:

Roman architects and engineers were able to construct amazing structures by utilizing several architectural structures little used previously: namely the dome, the arch, and the vault. These structures can carry immense weight by transmitting load through the curved axis (or circumference in the case of domes) to the supports, with little deflection or bending because the structure is already leaning on itself. As structurally and aesthetically superior structures, vaults, domes, and especially arches found their way into most roman structures: palaces, temples, amphitheaters, bridges, and aqueducts to name a few. The trend is named the Roman Architectural Revolution by historians, but it also goes by another name due to the revolutionary new material the Romans used to make these structures even stronger.

Internal Forces of Arches and Domes

Internal Forces of Arches and Domes

While discussing building materials in book II, Vitruvius describes this new material as “a kind of powder which, by nature, produces wonderful results. It is found in the neighbourhood of Baiae and in the lands of the municipalities round Mount Vesuvius. This being mixed with lime and rubble, not only furnishes strength to other buildings, but also, when piers are built in the sea, they set under water… when three substances formed in like manner by the violence of fire come into one mixture, they suddenly take up water and cohere together. They are quickly hardened by the moisture and made solid, and can be dissolved neither by the waves nor the power of water”. The powder he describes is pozzolona, volcanic ash and sand. While Vitruvius does not name the durable mixture of lime, rubble, and pozzolona, modern historians acknowledge it as ancient concrete.

Roman Pantheon

Roman Pantheon

Roman concrete has long puzzled historians and engineers. The Pantheon in Rome features the world’s largest unreinforced concrete dome, ranging from 6 to 1.5 meters (approx. 19.66 to 5 feet) in thickness and capable of containing a 43 meter (143ft) sphere. The Pantheon has lasted nearly 2000 years without steel reinforcement that would be required for modern concrete. In addition, many Roman bridges, aqueducts, and harbors still stand undeterred by thousands of years of weathering and erosion. Modern Portland cement, which has been in use since the 1800s, can only last 50 years of erosion in seawater. You can easily understand why Roman concrete has kept scientists scratching their heads.

Recently, it was identified that the mixture of lime and volcanic ash and rock undergoes a chemical reaction with seawater. The hydrated lime, with water molecules incorporated into its structure, reacted with the ash to form the cemented mixture. When used for underwater structures, the materials were mixed into basic mortar and packed into wooden forms, after which the surrounding water would cause the mixture. For building structures on land, the materials were mixed in a mortar box with little water to keep it dry and stiff (better for strength). Then the mixture was transported to the work site, placed over existing layers of stone, and pounded into the cracks. These ancient practices are being brought once again into the mainstream to create strong, lasting, and more eco-friendly concrete. As an example, in the construction of Utah’s Upper Stillwater Dam in 1987, the Bureau of Reclamation used a concrete mixture of 40% Portland cement, which contains the calcium component of lime, and 60% fly ash from power plants, which was found to contain the same amorphous silica compounds as volcanic ash. Bonding gel was used to bind rock pieces together, and the concrete was spread by vibrating rollers.

While modern concrete structures may not survive our century, the Roman concrete structures outlasted their civilization and are still sources of wonder. Its significance and widespread use in Roman engineering and construction is the reason some historians call the Roman Architectural Revolution “the concrete revolution”.

Roads:

“All roads lead to Rome,” it was said in the ancient world, and truly it would be impossible to mention the Romans’ building skills without mentioning their roads. The Romans borrowed the art of road-building from their neighbors the Etruscans, but like with everything else they assimilated the art was improved upon and used to its fullest potential.

Ancient Roman Road connecting Antioch with Chalcis - Tall Aqibrin, Syria

Ancient Roman Road connecting Antioch with Chalcis – Tall Aqibrin, Syria

Roads existed prior to the Romans, but most were more paths than roads, routes taken along the paths of least resistance between settlements. When travelling through mountains, deserts, and swamps, this could mean circuitous routes through dangerous country. It also placed limits on the movements of armies and merchants, who would have to choose routes their pack animals and carts could negotiate. The Romans were the first to build a substantial road network to provide direct, safe travel between cities. They also had the largest road system until the construction of modern highways, with roads spanning over 400,000 kilometers (250,000 miles), over 80,000 km (50,000 miles) were paved with stone. Roman roads were famously wide enough that an entire decanus, a legionary unit of ten men, could march shoulder to shoulder. Under the law of the Twelve Tables, established in 450 BC in the early Roman Republic, a standard road was required to be 8 feet (2.45 m) wide in straight sections and 16 feet (4.90 m) when curved. Over the centuries many roads differed from the standard, ranging from 4 to 30 feet (1.2 to 9m).

The majority of Roman roads were constructed by the legions. As the legions were already formed of able-bodied men and travelled constantly into new territory, it was convenient that they be put to work for the good of Rome. Amongst the legion’s ranks were a special unit of officers called the architecti, or chief builders, responsible for any military construction required of the legion. Under them were the agrimensores, land surveyors, and libratores, levelers, responsible for the layout of the road. Actual construction was done by the legionnaires, who in addition to carrying their armor, weapons, and rations were required to carry a set of building tools, including a saw, shovel, pickaxe, and hatchet. This strenuous work kept soldiers busy even in times of peace and helped build strength and stamina, although frequently local contractors and extensive slave labor supplemented the legionnaires’ work.

Roman Road Layers - From Shropshirehistory

Roman Road Layers – From Shropshirehistory

Road construction varied depending on terrain, soil conditions, and available materials, but Roman roads used layered roadbeds bordered by drainage ditches to siphon away rainwater that would otherwise damage the foundation of the road. The foundation itself could be a deep excavated trench (fossa) or a raised earthen embankment (agger). The foundation trench would be filled with gravel, stones, and rubble. If sand was available a layer of it would be put down. At about a meter (approx. 3.3 ft) from the surface a layer of gravel would be added and tamped down to form a pavement surface, called the pavimentum, which itself could function as a road surface or could support another layer of flat stones (statumen) set in cement to support further layers. Agger roads generally sufficed with their own earthen embankment of sand and gravel. Either of these two foundations would then support three further layers of metalling (broken stones): coarse concrete or rudus with larger stones, fine concrete or nucleas with smaller stones or compacted gravel, and finally the paving stones or crusta which made up the paved surface. The central paving stones were always taller than the surrounding ones, to give a curved surface that would channel rainwater to the drainage ditches.

 

(A). Native earth, leveled and, if necessary, rammed tight. (B). Statumen: stones of a size to fill the hand. (C). Audits: rubble or concrete of broken stones and lime. (D). Nucleus: kernel or bedding of fine cement made of pounded potshards and lime. (E). Dorsum or agger viae: the elliptical surface or crown of the road (media stratae eminentia) made of polygonal blocks of silex (basaltic lava) or rectangular blocks of saxum qitadratum (travertine, peperino, or other stone of the country). The upper surface was designed to cast off rain or water like the shell of a tortoise. The lower surfaces of the separate stones, here shown as flat, were sometimes cut to a point or edge in order to grasp the nucleus, or next layer, more firmly. (F). Crepido, margo or semita: raised footway, or sidewalk, on each side of the via. (G). Umbones or edge-stones.

(A). Native earth leveled and occasionally rammed tight.
(B). Statumen: hand-sized stones.
(C). Audits: rubble or concrete of broken stones and lime.
(D). Nucleus: kernel or bedding of fine cement made of pounded potshards and lime.
(E). Dorsum or agger viae: surface or crown of the road (media stratae eminentia) made of polygonal blocks of silex (basaltic lava) or rectangular blocks of saxum qitadratum (travertine, peperino, or other stone of the country). 
(F). Crepido, margo or semita: raised footway, or sidewalk, on each side of the via.
(G). Umbones or edge-stones.

Even after the fall of the Roman empire and the cessation of their maintenance, the Roman roads were utilized through the Medieval era for transportation and are still usable today, though not with comfort. The concrete cementing the paving stones together has eroded over the centuries and left very uneven surfaces, but in their prime the roman highways were as important to the empire as the US highway system is to its country and users. Using the roads, a legion could march up to 20 miles (32 km) a day and constructed a fortified camp (castra) at the roadside whenever the day’s march ended. Many frequent castra sites became permanent forts. Travelling officials and dignitaries, however, would not have entire legions to build stopping points nor would be satisfied with military accommodations. For this reason every 25 to 30km (approx. 16 to 19 miles), approximately the average distance travelled by an ox cart per day, mansiones were constructed as inns or villas that offered hospitality for travelers. These were normally reserved for those on official business, who were required to present passports for identification. Near the sites of the mansiones the less formal (and often disreputable) cauponae often served commoners, while more well-to-do but still unofficial travelers could stay at tabernae or hostels.

Remains of a Roman Mansio in  Staffordshire, England

Remains of a Roman Mansio in Staffordshire, England

Another type of way station commonly found along Roman highways were the mutationes, or changing stations, which serviced vehicles and animals. Located every 20 to 30 kilometers (12 to 19 miles) these establishments featured cartwrights and wheelwrights to repair chariots and wagons, veterinarians to treat animals, and spare animals to replace exhausted ones. With this system, official messengers and couriers could deliver messages quickly by riding hard and changing horses at the mutationes. A message could be transported an average 80km (50 miles) a day, but greater distances were theoretically achievable: the emperor Tiberius supposedly travelled 500 miles (800km) in just 24 hours to reach his dying brother.

Just as boom towns sprang up along American railroad lines, and the modern highway system is peppered with stores and service stations, infrastructure and businesses often sprang up to support these types of inns. Often permanent forts were constructed to defend the mansiones, and sometimes villages and even cities could be founded around them. The cities of Rheinzabern in Germany and Saverne in France are held to have begun as Roman stopping points. In this way, the Roman roads permitted their users to build and expand their empire.

Bridges:

As a general rule, the Romans preferred to build their roads as straight as possible. When faced with rocky terrain, hills, or ravines, the usual response was to cut through with excavations and tunnels. Detours were often made, but Roman roads were famed for their straightness, and weren’t bothered by little obstacles like rivers and mountains.

Alcantara Bridge, Spain

Alcantara Bridge, Spain

Romans were not the first to construct bridges, but they revolutionized bridge-building with their use of arches. As mentioned above, an arch transmits loading along its axis to the supports, enabling great load to be carried by simple columns. It also allows for wide gaps between tall supports, allowing floodwater to pass without rising over the top of the bridge, while giving the bridge the ability to carry up to its own weight. Single arches were sufficient for short spans, but for long distances the Romans used several arches in a single bridge. Segmented arches (not full semi-circles) were used to increase the length even further. The Limyra bridge in Turkey was constructed with 26 segmental arches over 330 meters (approx. 1089 feet) with an average span-to-rise ratio of 5.3 to 1, resulting in a flat profile that would not be repeated for over a millennium.

Bridge near Limyra, Turky

Bridge near Limyra, Turky

Stone and mortar were not the only materials the Romans used to build bridges. In addition to over three hundred stone bridges, engineer Colin O’Connor lists 34 timber bridges and 54 aqueduct bridges from the Roman era. A number of amazing Roman bridges have survived from antiquity are fully functional. Many, like the Pont Julien in France, are still capable of carrying car traffic. Others have even more impressive achievements: the Roman bridge at Vaison-la-Romaine, France, has survived bombing in World War II and flooding over two meters above the bridge deck (Ancient architecture: Roman bridges).

 

Roman bridge at Vaison-la-Romaine

Roman bridge at Vaison-la-Romaine

Aqueducts:

Roman Aqueduct of Segovia, Spain - 28 meters tall

Roman Aqueduct of Segovia, Spain – 28 meters tall

 Aside from the roads, the most famous example of Roman engineering is the aqueduct system. Like with the roads, Romans did not invent aqueducts. Aqueducts or canal systems were in use from the Mesopotamian era, but many of these were more like canals than the famous arch bridges that come to mind upon hearing the word aqueduct. These structures were the Romans’ work, and their use of these structures, like with their roads, became a defining feature of their empire. By the third century AD, Rome’s population of over a million was supplied, through a system of eleven aqueducts spanning over 500 miles (800km), with over one million cubic meters of water per day. This capacity is 26% greater than the modern water supply of Bangalore, India, whose population exceeds six million.

Pont du Gard, France

Pont du Gard, France

The arch bridges that symbolize the Roman aqueducts only represent a fraction (approx. only 30 miles of Rome’s system) of Roman aqueducts. The Romans generally tried to keep their aqueducts running within 0.5 to 1m beneath the surface, with bridges used to cross valleys, gorges, and rivers. When faced with deep or wide valleys, an alternative was an inverted siphon. Here the channel or conduit ended with a header tank. Using pressure and gravity the water would flow down the valley through pipes and cross at a “venter” bridge which would feed it to a lower receiving tank, from which it would continue along the channel.

Inverted Siphon on Roman Aqueduct

Inverted Siphon on Roman Aqueduct

They were also constructed with very low gradients: Vitruvius advises a gradient of at least 1:4800, while the Pont du Gard in France drops only 34 centimeters per kilometer, descending only 17m over its entire 50km length.

This dependence on aqueducts was rooted in a problem modern people can relate to. Rome’s river, the Tiber, was too polluted to drink safely. Water had to be brought in from elsewhere, and the aqueducts allowed water to be channeled from over 55 miles (90km) away. This allowed the Romans to overcome what was possibly the greatest obstacle to the growth of a city: in the past no city’s population could exceed the capacity of drinking and irrigation water provided by its nearby river. Think of the Nile in Egypt, or the Tigris and Euphrates in Mesopotamia, which enabled the civilizations around them to exist. With aqueducts to bring water from elsewhere, the Romans enjoyed public baths, fountains, and latrines. Farmers could also receive authorization to tap into aqueducts for irrigation water. All this required that the aqueducts be maintained, often by teams of slaves, laborers, and sometimes even legions to repair and clean the aqueducts regularly.

Sewers:

Cloaca Maxima opening into the Tiber (modern day)

Cloaca Maxima opening into the Tiber (modern day)

There was even a wastewater system to deal with the runoff. Around 800BC, centuries before Rome’s rise to power, a massive drainage system termed the Cloaca Maxima (greatest sewer in Latin, before ornithologists blanch) was constructed to drain nearby marshes around Rome into the Tiber River. The Romans suffered from malaria and other diseases spread by mosquitoes, and while they did not realize the mosquitoes’ role they recognized the role of stagnant water. Vitruvius himself advised strongly that cities not be built near marshes. Over the centuries more wastewater channels were constructed leading to the Cloaca Maxima, forming the basis for a sewer system. Continuous flow from the aqueducts flushed water from baths and latrines through channels to the Cloaca and other channels, eventually flushing the wastewater into the Tiber. Few private homes were connected to the system: most people had to use the public facilities or empty their chamber-pots into roadside sewage ditches that led to the main system.

Roman Sewage Ditch

Roman Sewage Ditch

 

Conclusion:

The Romans’ achievements would not be seen again for centuries after the fall of their empire. There is a very good reason the centuries following the fall of the empire were termed the Dark Ages. The Romans were not only the dominant power militarily, scientifically, and culturally, but because they had infrastructure that allowed the spread and advancement of their people like no civilization had before. Roads, bridges, aqueducts, sewers…modern civilization would be impossible without them, yet two thousand years ago the Romans were building an empire on them.

 

See Also:

(n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.vitruvius.be/boek2h6.htm
Ancient architecture: Roman bridges. (n.d.). Retrieved from Brightside: Bright Knowledge: http://www.brightknowledge.org/knowledge-bank/architecture/features-and-resources/ancient-architecture-roman-bridges
Ancient Roman Aqueducts. (n.d.). Retrieved from Crystallinks: http://www.crystalinks.com/romeaqueducts.html
Cartwright, M. (2012, 09 01). Aqueduct. Retrieved 12 14, 2014, from Ancient History Encyclopedia: http://www.ancient.eu/aqueduct/
Hansen, R. D. (n.d.). WATER AND WASTEWATER SYSTEMS IN IMPERIAL ROME. Retrieved from Water History: http://www.waterhistory.org/histories/rome/
History of Bridges. (n.d.). Retrieved from Crystallinks: http://www.historyofbridges.com/bridges-history/ancient-bridges/
Moore, D. (1995). The Pantheon. Retrieved 11 21, 2014, from romanconcrete.com: http://www.romanconcrete.com/docs/chapt01/chapt01.htm
Moore, D. (1993). The Riddle of Ancient Roman Concrete. Retrieved 11 21, 2014, from romanconcrete.com: http://www.romanconcrete.com/docs/spillway/spillway.htm
Pont Julien. (n.d.). Retrieved from Atlas Obscura: http://www.atlasobscura.com/places/pont-julien
Roads in Ancient Rome. (n.d.). Retrieved from Crystallinks: http://www.crystalinks.com/romeroads.html
Roman Road Construction. (n.d.). Retrieved from UNRV History: http://www.unrv.com/culture/roman-road-construction.php
Roman Roads. (n.d.). Retrieved from Shropshrire History: http://shropshirehistory.com/roads/romanroads.htm
Sánchez-Montaña, C. (n.d.). Who Vitruvius Was? Retrieved 11 21, 2014, from Vitruvii De Architectura: http://vitruviidearchitectura.blogspot.com/2006/10/vitruvii-de-architectura.html
Warner, B. (2013, 6 14). Ancient Roman Concrete Is About to Revolutionize Modern Architecture. Retrieved 11 21, 2014, from Businessweek.com: http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-06-14/ancient-roman-concrete-is-about-to-revolutionize-modern-architecture

Reach for the Sky

Welcome, readers, to Eye for Engineering’s first entry!

For this opening entry, I will begin with an account of an ambitious project currently under way: the soon-to-be tallest building in the world, Saudi Arabia’s Burj al Mamlakah, or Kingdom Tower.

Artist's Rendition of Kingdom Tower

Artist’s Rendition of Kingdom Tower

The project is under construction in the coastal city of Jeddah, on the Red Sea, beginning work in April 2013 and set for completion by 2018-2019. Once completed, the Kingdom Tower will not only be the tallest building in the world but will be the first building in recorded history to reach over a kilometer (0.625 miles) in height. At an estimated cost of US$1.23 to 1.5 billion, the project was conceived by Saudi Arabia’s Prince Al-Waleed Bin Talal, nephew of King Abdullah and chairman of the Kingdom Holding Company, Saudi Arabia’s largest investment firm and owners of the project.

Kingdom Tower Balcony

Kingdom Tower Balcony

The Kingdom Tower is set to feature a five-star Four Seasons Hotel with 200 rooms, more than 500 apartments, seven floors of offices, three sky lobbies, 58 elevators (some of them double-decked), an observatory on the top floors, and a 30 meters (approx. 100 ft) diameter balcony 660 meters off the ground. (Hanware, 2014) The tower will, in the words of architect Adrian Smith, “[represent] the new spirit in Saudi Arabia,” and that “symbolizes the Kingdom as an important global business and cultural leader, and demonstrates the strength and creative vision of its people.”

Post 1 Image 3

If all this sounds familiar to you, it is because Adrian Smith was also the architect for the current tallest building in the world: the Burj Khalifa in Dubai, across the Arabian Peninsula from Jeddah. The Burj Khalifa, at a height of 829.8 meters (2722 ft) and 163 floors, has held the world records since its completion in January 2010 as tallest free-standing structure, tallest building, highest number of stories, and highest occupied floor. It is so tall that above the 80th floor the sun is still visible even after setting on the ground. Burj Khalifa also includes the Armani Hotel Dubai, the Atmosphere restaurant, three swimming pools, offices, residential suites, and an observatory. It also has had an entire district designed around it: the development Downtown Dubai.

Left: Artist’s Rendition of Kingdom Tower; Center: Burj Khalifa; Right: Model of Frank Lloyd Wright’s Mile High Illinois at Milwaukee Art Museum

Left: Artist’s Rendition of Kingdom Tower; Center: Burj Khalifa; Right: Model of Frank Lloyd Wright’s Mile High Illinois at Milwaukee Art Museum

The quest for prestige by building the world’s tallest structure is nothing new; not with Saudi Arabia’s Kingdom Tower, nor Dubai’s Burj Khalifa. That ambition of man has been around since the Tower of Babel. Many historic and modern structures have claimed the title of tallest in the world in their day: the Great Pyramid at Giza, the Eiffel Tower, and the Empire State Building to name a few. Now, though, skyscrapers like the Burj Khalifa and the Kingdom Tower have reached into the domain of the megatall, having exceeded 600 meters in height. Soon the source of inspiration for these towers may become a reality itself: in his 1956 book A Testament, US architect Frank Lloyd Wright described plans for a mile-high (1.6 km) skyscraper The Illinois. While the Illinois was never constructed, Wright insisted it could be done with the materials and designs of his day, and many of his methods and suggestions have found their way into reality. Kingdom Tower was initially intended to reach a mile in height, but was shortened due to site limitations.

So what does it take to build a megatall skyscraper? How would Wright have done it, how did Burj Khalifa manage it, and how will Kingdom Tower manage it?

Area:

The first step in building such a large and costly building is to choose the best location. The build site is only the beginning – although substantial, as the Kingdom Tower’s site takes up 500,000 m2 (5,381,955 ft2) – as the surrounding area is often what determines the feasibility of the skyscraper.

Firstly, the skyscraper needs to have access to sustaining utilities: water and power come readily to mind. The Burj Khalifa’s water system supplies the tower with 946,000 liters of water daily, but still requires a condensate collecting system to meet water needs, as well as cooling needs of 10,000 tons (22.4 million lb) per hour. Once used, the water is allowed to run off by gravity into the municipal waste water system. The Burj also has a peak electrical requirement of 36 MW. These are all significant figures, and at first the municipality was unable to supply them. Shortly after opening the viewing platform had to be closed due to electrical problems, and at one point due to lack of adequate infrastructure the sewage was transported away by truck. Considering these issues in the center of wealthy Dubai, and considering that the area intended for the Kingdom Tower is undeveloped, the Kingdom Tower will require infrastructure to be built from scratch.

Needless to say, when these skyscrapers will literally and figuratively tower (pardon the pun) over everything in the area, it is important that they and the surrounding area complement each other. It is not only a matter of getting the best view or making sure the skyscraper isn’t an eyesore. The Kingdom Tower and Burj Khalifa cost an estimated US$1.5 billion each, so they must be optimally placed to make the best use of their iconic heights. That is why their creators are not only building towers.

View of Downtown Dubai from Burj Khalifa observation deck

View of Downtown Dubai from Burj Khalifa observation deck

Burj Khalifa has access to Downtown Dubai, a 2 square kilometer (0.77 square mile) complex of hotels, offices, residential buildings, the Dubai Fountain, the Burj Khalifa Park, and the massive Dubai Mall. While the Burj Khalifa and Downtown Dubai are part of the same project, altogether costing around 73 billion dirham (US $20 billion), the Burj has served mainly as a landmark and attraction for Downtown Dubai. Its main source of profit turned out to be the hotel rooms and apartments, while access to cheaper office spaces and lavish shopping in Downtown Dubai brought in the real profit for the project.

Dubai Fountain

Dubai Fountain

With that in mind, the construction of Kingdom City makes sense for the tower. Developed by the Jeddah Economic Company, a financial entity founded to develop the Kingdom Tower and City projects, Kingdom City will be a 5.2 km2 (2 square mile) development of commercial and residential buildings, which including the cost of the tower will bring the project cost up to SR75 billion (approx. US$20 billion). According to CEO Mounib Hammoud, the Kingdom Tower and City “is geared for Saudis, Saudi tourism, Saudi way of life, and nationals and religious visitors. Now, there is no destination for tourism in Arab world. Many people go to Dubai now, but once the project is ready they would like to stay in Saudi Arabia…The Kingdom Tower, City will be a gateway to the holy cities. It is about creating right infrastructure for making Jeddah a major destination for tourism and business hub.” While the success of making a business center to rival Dubai remains in question, the Kingdom Tower will not be able to stand alone.

In his design of the Illinois, Frank Lloyd Wright intended it to stand as the centerpiece of his imagined city of Broadacre. Rather than be a commercial district like Downtown Dubai and Kingdom City, Broadacre was Wright’s vision of how American cities should be made: with affordable housing, farming, public areas, and incorporated forests to contrast with the urban sprawl of his time. The Illinois was intended as the ultimate in conserving space, by expanding upward instead of outward – a concept Wright only embraced a few years before his death.

Site and Foundation:

Even once the surrounding area has been approved – or conformed, as in the three cases mentioned – no building is stronger than its foundation. Kingdom Tower’s builders discovered that when they performed the initial soil testing, and had to shorten the tower’s height from its original 1 mile (1.6km) target to the current one of 1km.

Raft Piling for Kingdom Tower Foundation

Raft Piling for Kingdom Tower Foundation

Constructing a foundation to support the Kingdom Tower and withstand the corrosive saltwater from the Red Sea took 12 months, with the end result being a thick steel-reinforced concrete raft over 4.5 meters thick, with 270 foundation piles ranging from 1.5 to 1.8m (5 to 6 ft) in diameter and 110m (330ft) in depth, courtesy of the Saudi BAUER Foundation Contractors Ltd. (BAUER Group). The reason for this depth is the same reason for the decrease in the tower’s final height: deposits of soft bedrock and porous coral beneath the site make the ground unstable, possibly causing unwanted settling for heavy buildings.

Burj Khalifa foundation mat and pilings

Burj Khalifa foundation mat and pilings

This design is similar to that used for the Burj Khalifa, although on a larger scale. The Burj Khalifa’s foundation consists of a concrete slab 3.7 meters thick and consisting of 12500 m3 (461575ft3) of concrete, supported by bored reinforced piles 1.5 meters in diameter and 43 meters deep (5ft and 143.33ft respectively). To resist seawater, the concrete was of high density but low permeability in both cases.

Foundation for Burj Khalifa

Foundation for Burj Khalifa

Structure:

As skyscrapers grow taller, problems begin to stack like the stories. To begin, each additional story increases the distributed loading on the same area, as the cross-sectional area cannot increase. In addition to the vertical loads, high rise buildings are at risk from lateral loads, as their area and height makes them susceptible to wind. The challenge then is to design a skyscraper with axial and lateral structural strength.

The first step is to select the best materials. Wright’s Illinois was intended to be made almost entirely from steel, as was usual for skyscrapers of the day, but while such a design may have been possible there would have been problems. Since Wright’s time there have been significant advances in developing high-strength concrete, making it the primary material.

Even so, applying concrete in high-rise buildings is not easy. Applying concrete had to be done at night when temperatures were low enough for the concrete to solidify, and had to be pumped through a pressurized tube to heights up to 601 meters from the ground, higher than required even by Taiwan’s Taipei 101. Also ice was added to the concrete during the mixing to accelerate cooling, and to so it would dry more evenly. Considering the height and location of Kingdom Tower, a similar method should be applied.

The Burj Khalifa and the Kingdom Tower use concrete with compressive strength of over 80 MPa (11.44 ksi) and 40 mm (1.6 in) diameter Grade 60 steel reinforcement bars of 520 MPa (74.36 ksi) yield strength. To put it in perspective, most buildings 10 stories tall and shorter use concrete with compressive strength 28 MPa (approx. 4 ksi) and steel reinforcement bars of 350 to 420 MPa (approx. 50 to 60 ksi) depending on what is available on the market. These strengths are nearly as high as steel can practically have, since higher than 500 MPa is only possible with more carbonized steel, which increases strength but loses ductility, thus defeating the point of using it as reinforcement for concrete.

Both the Burj Khalifa and the Kingdom Tower use clever arrangements of reinforced columns and structural shear walls to support not only the gravity load but also the lateral load from the wind. Wind load is an issue for any high-rise building, even for skyscrapers that do not reach the epic heights of the Burk Khalifa and the Kingdom Tower. The Empire State Building and Taipei 101, of 472.4m and 509m (1550ft and 1670ft) respective heights, also experience some swaying in the wind.

While Wright insisted that the Illinois could have been constructed in his day, the height would have caused difficulties considering his design. His steel-based tower was intended to have a tripod structure, similar to the later CN Tower, with cantilevered floors extending from the core “like branches on a tree”, in Wright’s words, to create the slender, tapering appearance of the tower. Such a structure made entirely from steel may have been possible even back in 1956, but would have been quite flexible in the wind. Wright had faith that the tensioned steel frame of his design would be able to resist oscillation in the wind, but later innovations would have improved the tower’s stability: higher strength concrete, for instance, but also a tuned mass damper such as that used in Taipei 101. A tuned mass damper reacts like a shock absorber, shifting in the opposite direction of sway to counteract oscillation.

Taipei 101’s Tuned Mass Damper

Taipei 101’s Tuned Mass Damper

Tall skyscrapers today are actually designed to sway slightly in the wind, so that by bending they avoid snapping. The trick is to minimize sway without eliminating it. Methods to accomplish this include deep foundations and wide bases, but the best method is proper design of the structure.

Burj Khalifa floorplan

Burj Khalifa floorplan

The Burj Khalifa’s entire structure is intended to stiffen the building and minimize the sway. The hexagonal core, with six columns and structural walls made from high-performance concrete, serves to resist torsion due to heavy wind. Extending from the hexagonal core through each of the three wings are buttressing structural walls which end in hammerhead walls. This arrangement is designed to act as the web and flanges of a beam to resist shear and moment – very clever, as it allows the walls and columns to share the lateral as well as vertical load.

Post 1 Image 11

The Burj’s setbacks – the decreasing area of the wings at upper floors – in addition to decreasing the distributed load per area, also serve to prevent the formation of wind vortices. When the wind parts around the building, it creates a low pressure area behind the building which the wind rushes to fill. This creates a vortex that can further sway the building. With the setbacks on the Burj Khalifa, however, the vortices are ‘shredded’, to quote architect Gordon Gill, who along with Adrian Smith was one of the chief architects of the project. The flow of wind and location of the vortices varies at each setback, preventing the formation of massive uniform vortices along the height of the Burj.

Despite the combination of these efforts, the Burj Khalifa’s tip still sways up to two meters in the wind. That is at the tip of the 200m (700ft) spire, however, leaving swaying even at the top floors negligible. Initial designs intended for a tuned mass damper to be added, but it was found unnecessary.

Kingdom Tower Floorplan

Kingdom Tower Floorplan

Adrian Smith + Gordon Gill Architecture (Smith and Gill had previously worked on the Burj Khalifa while working for Skidmore, Owings & Merill) is incorporating many similar principles in the creation of Kingdom Tower, but with different approaches, according to an interview with About Money. The Kingdom Tower shares Burj Khalifa’s Y-shaped footprint, but with a triangular core of shear walls. In design will be closer to Wright’s plan for the Illinois, consisting of three ‘legs’ which slowly taper upward and end at different heights. This is a departure from Burj Khalifa’s spiral of setbacks, which require that columns on upper floors align with structural walls below, but the design is equally capable of vortex shredding. This triangular shape is also oriented so that no side directly faces the sun, and also so that one side points towards Mecca.

Post 1 Image 13

To protect the concrete columns in the Burj Khalifa from damage from creep (degradation over time) and shrinkage (concrete changes size with hydration, age, and loading) the perimeter columns were constructed so that their own individual gravity stress matched the stress of interior walls. All load-bearing walls and columns were connected using five sets of outriggers, to reduce movement of individual elements due to creep, and as a final measure all perimeter columns were constructed with the same thickness of interior walls, 600mm (2ft), so that shrinkage of columns and walls would be uniform. Given the similar column and wall arrangement of the Kingdom Tower, reusing this method would be not only convenient but easy.

Service, Safety, and Accessibility:

Supporting itself physically is only one requirement. People and cargo must be able to get in, out, and through the building with relative ease.

The one thing that does NOT need to transfer easily through these two towers in the Middle East is heat. With average temperatures of around 45 °C (113 °F) in Dubai and Jeddah, good air conditioning and thermal insulation are crucial. Burj Khalifa is clad in 142,000 m2 (1,528,000 ft2) of reflective glazing, aluminum and textured stainless steel spandrel panels, and stainless steel vertical tubular fins to accentuate its height. It amounts to nearly 26,000 glass panels, requiring the project to bring in over 300 cladding specialists from China to work on the Burj’s cladding.

Post 1 Image 14

Kingdom Tower will also feature a low-conductivity glass exterior to reduce heat transfer, as well using a series of notches on its side to provide pockets of shadow, perfect for terraces. It would be very convenient for the 1km tower to imitate one of the Burj Khalifa’s innovative cooling systems. Since the air at such altitudes is much cooler than near the ground, the Burj takes in the cooler air and uses it in the air conditioning. Air conditioning devices, as well as mechanical, electrical, and plumbing systems, are housed in seven double-height mechanical floors distributed among the residential floors.

Post 1 Plumbing

People, on the other hand, need unrestricted mobility. The Burj Khalifa has a capacity of 35,000 people and the Kingdom Tower will have even more, and since nobody will travel hundreds of meters down the stairs, numbers of elevators are needed, hence another reason for the open core design of the towers. The Burj Khalifa and Kingdom tower respectively have 57 and 58 elevators, travelling 10 to 12 meters per second (33 to 40ft/sec), and will both feature double-decker elevators. Smith even intended to install the world’s first triple-deck elevators in the Burj Khalifa, but the final design did not exceed two cabs.

Post 1 Elevators

Wright was even more ambitious in his design. His Mile-High Illinois, in a typical 50s vision of future grandeur, would include 76 atomic-powered five-deck elevators capable of travelling 60 mph (a mile per minute, or 27 meters per second) on ratchets instead of cables. There is a good reason these vertical trains haven’t become reality yet: Wright was an architect, not a meteorologist or a mechanical engineer. At an altitude of 914m (3000ft) the air pressure has dropped nearly ten percent. Travelling upward at high speeds can cause nausea and even unconsciousness. For this reason not only will the speed of the elevators be limited to the aforementioned values, but each building will include three sky lobbies where people may alternate between elevators. This adds a few minutes to the trip but allows it to be done comfortably. An advantage of Wright’s vertical trains is that the building could be evacuated within an hour in an emergency, while Smith’s designs for the Burj Khalifa force it to rely on pressurized, fireproof refuge floors every 25 stories. The Kingdom Tower will feature even more, according to JEC CEO Mounib Hammoud: “eight double height refuge floors…allocated, every twenty floors, throughout the tower.”

Wright had another trick up his sleeve for access and evacuation of upper floors: his design for the Illinois included parking for 150 helicopters.

Conclusion:

            All three of these towers – the Burj Khalifa, the Kingdom Tower, and Mile-High Illinois – while similar in design and intent, are all shining examples of breaking the mould, pushing the limits of contemporary engineering and architecture. Perhaps in the future, when such high-rise buildings become the norm, the principles and methods cited in this blog will become commonplace, and we will all wonder how people managed to live in short, tiny buildings.

Thanks for reading!

Thanks for reading!

See Also;

1) (n.d.). Retrieved 10 28, 2014, from Kingdom Tower Skyscraper: http://www.kingdomtowerskyscraper.com/

2) Allianz Report Sets Out Risks of Supertall Towers. (2014, 6 25). Retrieved 10 28, 2014, from The Construction Index: http://www.theconstructionindex.co.uk/news/view/allianz-sets-out-risks-of-building-supertall-towers

3) BAUER Group. (n.d.). Bauer constructs Foundations for Kingdom Tower and Lakhta Tower. Retrieved 10 29, 2014, from BAUER Group: https://www.bauer.de/en/career/newsletter/2012-10/kingdom_tower_lakhta_tower.html

4) Belleza, I. E. (2010, 1 4). Burj Khalifa: Towering challenge for builders. Retrieved 10 28, 2014, from GulfNews: http://gulfnews.com/business/property/burj-khalifa-towering-challenge-for-builders-1.561802

5) Gibbon, G. (2014, 4 24). Foundation work completed on Jeddah’s Kingdom Tower. Retrieved 10 29, 2014, from arabianbusiness.com: http://www.arabianbusiness.com/foundation-work-completed-on-jeddah-s-kingdom-tower-547750.html#.VFEmy_mUe2k

6) Hanware, K. (2014, 4 24). Iconic Jeddah Kingdom Tower construction work gathers pace. Retrieved 10 28, 2014, from Arab News: http://www.arabnews.com/news/560441

7) Mandour, A. (2009, 3 19). Burj Dubai’s Inspiration the Mile High Illinois. Retrieved 10 28, 2014, from Construction Week Online: http://www.constructionweekonline.com/article-4701-burj_dubais_inspiration_the_mile_high_illinois/

8) Materials – Burj Khalifa. (n.d.). Retrieved from Google Sites: https://sites.google.com/site/burjkhalifatower/directory

9) Mawani, V. (2011, 8 5). Kingdom Tower by Bin Laden Group will be the World’s Tallest Building. Retrieved 10 28, 2014, from IndustryLeaders Magazine: http://www.industryleadersmagazine.com/kingdom-tower-by-bin-laden-group-will-be-the-worlds-tallest-building/

10) Peter Weismantle & Alejandro Stochetti, A. S. (2013). Kingdom Tower, Jeddah. Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat .

11) Rodriguez, J. (n.d.). World Tallest Building- Kingdom Tower. Retrieved 10 31, 2014, from About Money: http://construction.about.com/od/Future-Projects/a/World-Tallest-Building-Kingdom-Tower.htm

12) Schmidt, J. R. (2011, 8 25). Frank Lloyd Wright’s mile-high building. Retrieved 10 29, 2014, from WBEZ91.5: http://www.wbez.org/blog/john-r-schmidt/2011-08-25/frank-lloyd-wrights-mile-high-building-90793

13) Schumacher, M. L. (2011, 2 10). REVIEW: Frank Lloyd Wright at the Milwaukee Art Museum. Retrieved 10 28, 2014, from Journal Sentinel Online: http://www.jsonline.com/blogs/entertainment/115744074.html

14) STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS — ELEVATORS, SPIRE, AND MORE. (n.d.). Retrieved from Burj Khalifa: http://www.burjkhalifa.ae/en/TheTower/Structures.aspx

15) Urstadt, B. (2014, 3 20). Architects Gordon Gill and Adrian Smith on Building the World’s Tallest Towers. Retrieved 10 31, 2014, from BusinessWeek: http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-03-20/architects-gordon-gill-adrian-smith-on-building-the-worlds-tallest-towers

16) William F. Baker, D. S. (n.d.). Engineering the World’s Tallest – Burj Dubai. Retrieved 10 30, 2014, from Cement.org: cement.org/buildings/Burj%20CTBUH.pdf

17) Burj Khalifa – Civil Engineering Seminar – http://civilenggseminar.blogspot.com/2011/09/burj-khalifa.html

18) Visit the Burj Khalifa – http://www.burjkhalifa.ae/en/

Eye for Engineering – An Introduction

Welcome, all visitors, to Eye for Engineering, a blog exhibiting and discussing works of engineering of any field.       

I, the writer, am a college civil engineering student with engineering in his blood.  My father is an architect/civil engineer who along his career has worked on houses, bridges, and high-rise buildings, in addition to teaching engineering at several universities. I also have a brother going into mechanical engineering, and between us we have a treasure trove of information to share. I like to think of myself as a connoisseur of engineering – someone with great taste and interest. I am more than a fan, but not yet an expert. I am a connoisseur, and I dedicate this blog to all fellow connoisseurs and enthusiasts.

This blog will mainly feature analysis of engineering projects: their locations, specifications, engineering principles, uniqueness, successes, and failures. Such projects may come from any field of engineering – mechanical, civil, or structural – so topics of analysis may include cars, roads, and trains alongside bridges and buildings. These projects may be taken from any period in history, so historic accounts may appear alongside proposed projects for the future. In addition, certain past or present figures in engineering may be discussed in tributary pieces.

Eye for Engineering exists as an insightful window into the universe of engineering. Stay tuned for the latest pieces!